| 2008 |
| Dennis K. Burns, M.D. | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1971 |
| Bill Jackson | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1959 |
| Jeffrey B. Light | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1974 |
| William E. Metzger, Jr. | Central High School | Class of 1940 |
| Martin C. Spechler, Ph.D. | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1960 |
| Anthony Karl (A.T.) Thompson, Sr. | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1984 |
| Cheryl Tschanz | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1974 |
| Rev. Dr. Franklin J. Upthegrove | Central High School | Class of 1941 |
| Sheldon Z. Yessenow, D.V.M. | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1967 |
| Sally (Coup) Moomaw, Ed.D. | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1967 |
| 2005 |
| John R. Barton | South High School | Class of 1954 |
| Joe Bowers | South High School | Class of 1927 |
| Meg Guyton Dickason | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1962 |
| Francine (Edelman) Friedman | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1966 |
| Ronald M. Gross | Central High School | Class of 1951 |
| Kathie Hammond | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1967 |
| Robert Wade King | Central High School | Class of 1924 |
| Kerry L. Nelson | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1971 |
| Catherine R. Mack | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1962 |
| Emmett Murray, Jr., M.D. | Central High School | Class of 1943 |
| David Reynolds | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1964 |
| Charles M. Ridenour | Central High School | Class of 1932 |
| J. Michael Romey | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1969 |
| Walter L. White | Central High School | Class of 1937 |
| 2002 |
| Colonel Patricia L. Accountius, USA Ret. | South High School | Class of 1948 |
| James R. Foulkes, M.D. | Central High School | Class of 1945 |
| Horace F. Greene, M.D. | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1957 |
| Wayne A. "Johnnie" Johnson | Central High School | Class of 1949 |
| J. Timothy Riker, RADM, USCGR | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1966 |
| Jack L. Saine | South High School | Class of 1950 |
| Robert G. Smith | South High School | Class of 1953 |
| Donald F. Steiner, M.D. | Central High School | Class of 1948 |
| Bert Stimmel | Central High School | Class of 1939 |
| David C. Wright, PH.D. | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1972 |
| 1999 |
| Scott Clark | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1971 |
| Roger Daniel | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1972 |
| Anita (Heil) Gallentine | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1973 |
| Grover W. William Hall, Jr. | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1962 |
| Clarice Gamble Herbert | Central High School | Class of 1934 |
| William Edward Holden, M.D. | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1960 |
| Mark A. Johnson, D.V.M. | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1963 |
| Howard M. Keller | Central High School | Class of 1941 |
| David and Robert Lepo | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1969 |
| Robert E. Maxwell, M.D., Ph.D. | South High School | Class of 1954 |
| Ross R. Olney | South High School | Class of 1947 |
| George Leslie Thompson | Central High School | Class of 1934 |
| James R. Tobin, Jr. | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1962 |
| William E. White | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1984 |
| J. Joe Yazel, M.D. | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1963 |
| 1996 |
| Thomas Barrington | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1962 |
| Lt. Col. Keith Briem | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1970 |
| Phillip Broyles | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1973 |
| Dr. Carolyn Clemons Callahan | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1967 |
| Dr. Robert C. Flanigan | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1964 |
| Dr. John A. E. Hubbell | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1970 |
| Sue Weisenbarger Kelly | Central High School | Class of 1954 |
| Dr. J. Michael McBride | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1958 |
| Diane Harter Tidd | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1966 |
| Joe B. Webb | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1966 |
| Maralyn Hope West | South High School | Class of 1946 |
| Charles I. Williams | Central High School | Class of 1935 |
| 1993 |
| Royal Gaines Albridge | South High School | Class of 1951 |
| Karen Snurr Andrews | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1966 |
| Donald Campbell | Central High School | Class of 1953 |
| Phyllis Diller | Central High School | Class of 1935 |
| Joseph Henderson | South High School | Class of 1953 |
| Roger L. Miller | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1961 |
| Gary Moeller | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1959 |
| Joe Morrison | South High School | Class of 1955 |
| Maidie Norman, HLD | Central High School | Class of 1930 |
| Waldo Bennett Rose | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1957 |
| Father Robert C. Seay, OFM | Central High School | Class of 1952 |
| Harrison Shutt | Central High School | Class of 1950 |
| 1990 |
| Lt. Martha Baumberger Cramer | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1967 |
| Dr. William Alfred Fowler | Central High School | Class of 1929 |
| Dr. Susan L. Hubbell | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1968 |
| Dr. David W. Roush | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1967 |
| Dwight E. Shambley | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1968 |
| Kathy O'Hara Light Smith | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1968 |
| Dr. David B. Steiner | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1957 |
| Merlyn C. Sykes | South High School | Class of 1940 |
| Admiral James L. Taylor, U.S.N. | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1961 |
| John D. Whittington | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1964 |
| Gordon Lee Wildermuth | South High School | Class of 1955 |
| Patricia Williams Wildermuth | South High School | Class of 1955 |
| 1987 |
| Dr. James Baugh | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1960 |
| Jeanette Chambers | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1962 |
| Captain David Deitrick | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1968 |
| James P. Fisher | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1956 |
| Frank Gordon Love | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1967 |
| Dr. Joseph Metz | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1958 |
| Belle Heffner Mickelson | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1966 |
| Dr. Ronald W. Richards | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1959 |
| Dr. Craig Snapp | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1962 |
| Scott Spangler | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1956 |
| Janet Roush Taylor | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1959 |
| Thomas Worrall | Lima Senior High School | Class of 1960 |